These jeans are perfection. I'm 5'4, 150lbs and got a 29 petite because they have no stretch. (I wear a 28 if there is stretch.) I got so many compliments wearing these. I purchased the light wash and they are excellent quality.

I agree with the other reviews, the quality is awful. Which was shocking, because Gap has really been I increasing quality elsewhere. These were flattering, however, I couldn't justify keeping them based on quality alone.

Definitely too cropped for a barrel jean. Also there's zero stretch and they are super thin. Wanted to love these but they are just not it.

I just wrote a review, was going to keep them, tried them on again and I can't get past the quality. I'd stick with the original high-rise barrel jeans.

These jeans are super flattering and feel great. They do not have any stretch in them and are more structured. I went with tall because I didn't want a crop length. I'm 5'8 and usually wear a 28/29 depending on the fit. I went with 29 in these for a less snug and more relaxed fit.

I'm 5'1 and these hit at my ankle. I have the high-rise Barrel Jean in the dark and lighter wash, I have to roll them. I thought this would be a better fit, I wish they were an inch shorter. I that got the darker wash in the crop, and the fabric is thinner than the other barrel jeans, not as good quality. Also has a scent, it's not horrible but it's there. They are not as dark as seen online. Definitely more of a medium wash. I will keep them because they are flattering, I'm just disappointed with the quality. And wish I could actually purchase a crop petite jean.