Reviews

Review Snapshot
4.4
103 Star Ratings
54%
of respondents would recommend this to a friend
Ratings Distribution
Overall size
Most Liked Positive Review
Black pair smells bad during wash

I have 3 pairs of these jeans in different colours because they're cute, comfy and fit well for my body type. My only complaint is with the black pair specifically, it developed a strong metallic (rusty iron) smell after washing that WON'T go away no matter how many times I've washed it. I don't hav...

Versus
Most Liked Negative Review
Got smaller

I own these from last year in dark wash and love them. I am 5'1 and got the xxs regular length as I didn't want them cropped. This year, I ordered the cream colour in petite xs and I don't like the way the waist fits. Colour is pretty and maybe would work in regular length but this didn't work for m...

Write a Review
91 Customer Reviews
Love

Submitted 4 days ago

By anonymous

From Undisclosed

Height 5'11"

Verified Buyer

Sweepstakes Entry

Comments about Mid Rise UltraSoft Easy Horseshoe Jeans

I love the deep pockets and comfy feel

Baggy but flattering

Submitted 6 days ago

By Hayley F

From Undisclosed

Weight 100–110 lbs

Height 5'1"

Reviewed at

gap.com/

I am 5ft1, 100lbs, waist 24.5 inches. I purchased the dark indigo colored pants and loved them so much that I purchased the pink and ballerina blue too. The colors are true to the ones in the website. I got the pants in Petite XS. They are loose which I like. If they have the XXS, I believe it would be a perfect fit for me. I wear the pants mid rise, and the hem just touches below my ankles, which is exactly what I like.

Huge

Submitted 11 days ago

By Charlotte, T

From Undisclosed

I got my normal size, XL after reading other reviews thinking that they'd be a little loose and comfortable for a casual look. Wow… They are absolutely huge. Should have gone down at least 1 size. #sweepstakes

Very Big

Submitted 14 days ago

By Simone D

From Undisclosed

Cute and comfy but unfortunately just too big. The last jeans I ordered at Gap were the equivalent of a 14 and I couldn't get them done up so I went with an XL in these and they are HUGE. Real shame because the fabric was nice and comfy. I'll be returning these but may purchase again a size smaller next time they're on sale.

OBSESSED with these jeans.

Submitted 16 days ago

By anonymous

From Undisclosed

Height 5'3"

Verified Buyer

Sweepstakes Entry

Comments about Mid Rise UltraSoft Easy Horseshoe Jeans

OBSESSED with these jeans. I'm 5'3 and midsize and on the low have felt down in the past from not finding proper horse shoe or barrel jeans that fit my body well but I've never found a pair more flattering. I want these in every color

So chic and effortless

Submitted 17 days ago

By Liz G

From Undisclosed

Weight 110–120 lbs

Height 5'4"

Reviewed at

gap.com/

Flowy drapey flattering. Took my usual size, XS. They're loose but that's the style

My fav pants

Submitted 18 days ago

By Mac P

From Undisclosed

Weight 160–170 lbs

Height 5'8"

Reviewed at

gap.com/

These are the best. I'm 5'8 160lbs and got a M tall. They are perfect length on me (I like my pants to touch the ground) and are baggy, I have to tie them all the way tight. They are great in summer or winter. Neeeeed more washes/colors of it.

Very flattering and yet comfortable

Submitted 26 days ago

By Mary, jan

From Undisclosed

Reviewed at

gap.com/

It will give you a nice hips for apple shape figure . Im 5'1 and petite is perfect

Great pant, inconsistent sizing

Submitted 27 days ago

By Eliza B.

From Undisclosed

Weight 150–160 lbs

Height 5'6"

Reviewed at

gap.com/

I have these in three colors and love them so much — truly my favorite pants ever. Great for fall or spring in the south. I'm typically a medium/8, and I ordered a medium in all three colors, but the fit varies a lot by color. The blue stripe pair is soft, relaxed, and full-length. The dark purple pair is a little stiffer, but still relaxed and full-length. The cream pair runs much smaller and stiffer, and fits almost like a cropped capri on me. I still kept and wear all three, but if I'd known about the fit difference, I definitely would have sized up to a large in the cream.

Perfect

Submitted 29 days ago

By Jess O

From Undisclosed

Weight 150–160 lbs

Height 5'9"

Reviewed at

gap.com/

I went with a medium tall, normally I'm between a 4-6 in pants. Currently 6 months pregnant so I just stayed with the same size since it is a stretch waistband. These are long enough for my 5'9 height I normally like an inseam of 33-35. Yes they are baggy but that's how they are shown in the images so no complaints there. I do like them as a baggy fit. They are soft denim. I purchased two different colors and they both fit the same. Normally I'm 150lb and pregnancy currently at 170 and I would still stick with the medium just out of comfort. They are kind of like a baggy sweatpants look but in denim. Sooo stinkin cute and so easy to style