Skip to top navigationSkip to shopping bagSkip to main contentSkip to footer links

Reviews

Review Snapshot
3.5
25 Star Ratings
25%
of respondents would recommend this to a friend
Ratings Distribution
Overall size
Most Liked Positive Review
Flattering but short

I love that these are 100% cotton with no stretch - it gives them great structure. I also love the light wash - it's the perfect colour for summer. But they are super cropped. I am 5'2" and got the petite. Thinking I will return for the regular fit so I have the option to cuff them for a shorter fit...

Versus
Most Liked Negative Review
Not as great quality as the other barrel jeans

I'm 5'1 and these hit at my ankle. I have the high-rise Barrel Jean in the dark and lighter wash, I have to roll them. I thought this would be a better fit, I wish they were an inch shorter. I that got the darker wash in the crop, and the fabric is thinner than the other barrel jeans, not as goo...

Write a Review
25 Customer Reviews
Barrel looked too wide on me

Submitted 8 days ago

By anonymous

From Undisclosed

Height 5'2"

Verified Buyer

Sweepstakes Entry

Reviewed at

gap.com/

Comments about High Rise Crop Barrel Jeans

I am 5'2" and the regular length was perfect in a size 26 regular, but I thought the barrel was a little too wide for me and I would have liked the front panel material where the zipper is to be a little more fitted, it felt like there was too much material. I do not think a size down would have helped any. I usually wear a 26 petite, but sometimes I think petite cropped pants are a little too cropped for me and it makes me look shorter. The 26" regular landed just at my ankle and looked great length wise.

Fit true to size and good denim

Submitted 8 days ago

By Sue B

From Undisclosed

Weight 160–170 lbs

Height 5'9"

Reviewed at

gap.com/

I'm so confused by these reviews. I love these. I ordered my size and one size up. My usual size fit just right so I didn't even try the one size up. I found them to have a relaxed fit. If you were looking for tighter through the waist and hip area you might size down. But if you want kind of the casual fit then I found these to be true to size. I love the quality with the denim - feels like solid midweight. I like that the barrel is not too exaggerated. I'm 5'9" and got regular fit. Everyone's legs are a different length, but I found these to fit more like a 28" inch inseam on me which I wouldn't call a crop. Keeping and may try other colors, but being careful not to have too many barrels in the closet!

Wanted to love these

Submitted 10 days ago

By Natalie Q.

From Undisclosed

Reviewed at

oldnavy.gap.com

I ordered the medium wash in a size 31 short (not petite) and liked them but wanted to try the regular length to see if I liked that better. The short length has a 24" inseam. The regular length arrived (medium wash size 31) and it looked a lot different than the short pair. The wash was different and the material felt cheap. I ordered the 31 medium wash regular length again hoping to get a pair that looked like the short length, which I did but they were too tight in the waist which didn't make sense because the short pair were slightly loose at the waist which I appreciated. There seems to be an issue with consistency with these jeans. Unfortunately they're all going back because I didn't love any of them for almost $100. I'm 5'2" 150lbs and normally a size 30 for reference.

Perfect summer jeans!

Submitted 11 days ago

By aliS

From Undisclosed

Weight 110–120 lbs

Height 5'0"

Reviewed at

gap.com/

I have ordered the light wash in petite 25 which is true to size for me. The denim is lightweight and soft. I am 5ft 112lbs. If you are toller than 5ft these be more cropped on you than they are on the model. They hit me at right above the ankle. The rise is perfect, barely hits the belly button. Good barel option for petite body.

Nice jeans

Submitted 15 days ago

By Natalie

From Undisclosed

Reviewed at

oldnavy.gap.com

I ordered the medium wash in a size 31 SHORT (not petite). I am 5'2" 150lbs and always wear a size 30. I sized up after reading reviews and I do feel like that was a good choice for my preference. The wash and material on these jeans are nice. I am contemplating ordering the 31 regular length because I truly just need one more inch in the length to feel like these jeans could be worn year round. I couldn't find any measurements for the inseam lengths on cropped jeans. The pair I received (short length) has a 24" inseam. I do feel like these have a pretty big barrel cut (some barrel jeans are more subtle) and that's honestly my biggest hang up. I'm not sure if a little more length would help, if I need to just own that look because besides that I love these jeans or if these just aren't the jeans for me.

Nice barrel Jean

Submitted 17 days ago

By anonymous

From Undisclosed

Height 5'9"

Verified Buyer

Sweepstakes Entry

Comments about High Rise Crop Barrel Jeans

I like the fit and length in tall. Will be exchanging for the darker colour. #sweepstakes

Size fits well

Submitted 24 days ago

By anonymous

From Undisclosed

Height Under 5'0"

Verified Buyer

Sweepstakes Entry

Comments about High Rise Crop Barrel Jeans

Length (inseam) is perfect for my 4'9" height, pricey, but worth it. I am usually a size 27 but 28 waistline is just right so i can move comfortably and still able to tuck my shirt without constricting my breathing

Nice for summer

Submitted 1 month ago

By anonymous

From Undisclosed

Height 5'4"

Verified Buyer

Sweepstakes Entry

Comments about High Rise Crop Barrel Jeans

Light weight denim perfect for summer

SO small

Submitted 1 month ago

By Michaela B

From Undisclosed

Weight 170–180 lbs

Height 5'8"

Reviewed at

gap.com/

I have a different wash of these jeans already in the size I bought and they are loose on me so I purchased the same size just incase because all pants are different but these are WAY too small!! I feel like I may have to go even two sizes up I couldnt even fit them over my butt and cannot button them. make it make sense!!!

Lightweight, no stretch, difficult to find size

Submitted 1 month ago

By Bertie

From Undisclosed

Height 5'10"

Reviewed at

gap.com/

Great jean, appreciate it's weight for the summer and I like the dark wash. However, jean is small in waist and rear. No stretch denim is my thing, and I almost always size up one for comfort. This, sized up, is tight! I was having a difficult time breathing kind of tight. Get your sizing right, and I don't think you'll be disappointed.