Skip to top navigationSkip to shopping bagSkip to main contentSkip to footer linksSkip to offers

Reviews

Review Snapshot
4.5
2238 Star Ratings
85%
of respondents would recommend this to a friend
Ratings Distribution
Chest
Length
Overall size
Most Liked Positive Review
TOO big shirt

I own multiple colours of this shirt that I have bought over the past few years. They're definitely a closet staple for me. I just bought the pink and red stripe one though, and this new one is somewhat different from my old ones. The fabric feels a little heavier, the shape of the hem is different,...

Versus
Most Liked Negative Review
New styles have a different fit from previous years

Bought this shirt last year in black and white and I wear them all the time, they are closet staples for me. I would give this item 5 stars for last year's version. I typically wear M Petite (L Petite for some styles that are more fitted or have little stretch) but S Petite in this shirt is still pe...

Write a Review
2051 Customer Reviews
Best shirts

Submitted 3 days ago

By anonymous

From Undisclosed

Height 5'3"

Verified Buyer

Sweepstakes Entry

Comments about Organic Cotton Poplin Big Shirt

Gap poplin shirts are the best. However, this year they are very big.

Updated- Poor quality dye

Submitted 4 days ago

By Meg

From Undisclosed

Weight 100–110 lbs

Height Under 5'0"

Love the material and quality of the fabric. The shirt was too big on me (purchased XS petite) and if was 16 weeks pregnant when purchased, so i had to take it in, and then it was an attractive amount of oversized. Just washed it for the first time (purchased the pink colour) and the colour is so faded with blotches of faded dye all over. My photos make the colour look brighter than it is in real life. So disappointed, as I washed in cold water with gentle wash.

Yes Please!

Submitted 9 days ago

By anonymous

From Undisclosed

Height 5'5"

Verified Buyer

Sweepstakes Entry

Reviewed at

gap.com/

Comments about Organic Cotton Poplin Big Shirt

Super basic and great essential. Very comfortable

Nice and soft

Submitted 9 days ago

By anonymous

From Undisclosed

Verified Buyer

Sweepstakes Entry

Comments about Organic Cotton Poplin Big Shirt

Soft, feels nice, oversized indeed

The best shirt!

Submitted 11 days ago

By anonymous

From Undisclosed

Height 5'10"

Verified Buyer

Sweepstakes Entry

Comments about Organic Cotton Poplin Big Shirt

This is my favourite shirt and is the second one I have purchased! I wore my first to death so I was so happy to be able to get a second one. The fabric is amazing, washes up fantastic. It is so versatile. I have worn it as beach cover, with jeans/shorts and a tee and over t-shirt dresses! It is a must have piece for travelling!

The navy stripe does not look good in person

Submitted 13 days ago

By Niko

From Undisclosed

I've been buying these since I came out, they changed the design. The cuff and the collar. I much prefer the old style. The collar in this one is too big to pop. And doesn't look as good with the sleeves rolled out. I was excited to see the navy, but in person it didn't look great, return.

Awful design changes

Submitted 16 days ago

By anonymous

From Undisclosed

Height 5'4"

Verified Buyer

Sweepstakes Entry

Comments about Organic Cotton Poplin Big Shirt

I'm so disappointed in the design changes to the big shirt. This has always been a staple in my wardrobe. The shirts I just received have massive cuffs and collars, notably different than older shirts. I feel like a waiter from the 70s. Please bring back the old design!

Oversized!

Submitted 16 days ago

By anonymous

From Undisclosed

Height 5'5"

Verified Buyer

Sweepstakes Entry

Reviewed at

gap.com/

Comments about Organic Cotton Poplin Big Shirt

Love it!. My kind of shirt you can style this shirt multiple ways!

Size down twice!

Submitted 17 days ago

By anonymous

From Undisclosed

Height 5'5"

Verified Buyer

Sweepstakes Entry

Comments about Organic Cotton Poplin Big Shirt

I'm usually an L in gap shirts but in the brown and blue "big shirt" style I needed a small to get that oversized look without too much body fabric. Easy and effortless! I like that this style has buttons above the wrist towards the elbow, seems to hold up a fold better and firm around the arm.

HUGE!!!

Submitted 20 days ago

By Debra M.

From Undisclosed

Weight 110–120 lbs

Height 4'11"

Reviewed at

gap.com/

I purchased a Petite XS - it doesn't come any smaller. It still swallowed me!! I am short - 4'!!", but still! If even the smallest size is so much too big it's made too beg. The color was great and the feel of the fabric was soft and luxurious which is why I gave it 2 stars. I wanted this shirt to fit!