Reviews

Review Snapshot
4.5
2079 Star Ratings
85%
of respondents would recommend this to a friend
Ratings Distribution
Chest
Length
Overall size
Most Liked Positive Review
TOO big shirt

I own multiple colours of this shirt that I have bought over the past few years. They're definitely a closet staple for me. I just bought the pink and red stripe one though, and this new one is somewhat different from my old ones. The fabric feels a little heavier, the shape of the hem is different,...

Versus
Most Liked Negative Review
New styles have a different fit from previous years

Bought this shirt last year in black and white and I wear them all the time, they are closet staples for me. I would give this item 5 stars for last year's version. I typically wear M Petite (L Petite for some styles that are more fitted or have little stretch) but S Petite in this shirt is still pe...

Write a Review
1902 Customer Reviews
Just okay

Submitted 2 days ago

By Dee.H

From Undisclosed

Weight 110–120 lbs

Height 5'0"

Reviewed at

gap.com/

Yes this runs on the large size , I usually wear a petite medium so I ordered petite small and it was loose I could have ordered and xtra small. I washed and dried it , did not really shrink. It's just okay I had to iron it to get it to look good. Kind of a stiff shirt. I think it's overpriced. The only thing I like about it is the color .

Ugly oxford blue shirt

Submitted 3 days ago

By Lindsay, K

From Undisclosed

Reviewed at

gap.com/

Did not like this shirt at all! Looked like a grandpas old work shop shirt, not feminine at all. The huge and awkward fit, the heavy feel, the masculine cut, all unattractive and not up to par for gap. Ordered 3 different button down shirts and they all fit so different, no consistency. Returned entire order the next day. Disappointed. Bring back classic/perfect, feminine cut, attractive shirts for women in fun colors!

Very Large Should Have Sized Down

Submitted 5 days ago

By A Harwell

From Georgia

Reviewed at

gap.com/

Love the blue striped shirt expected oversized but it is very large! I will decide over the next few days if I will keep it.

Perfect petite button down shirt.

Submitted 5 days ago

By anonymous

From Undisclosed

Height 5'2"

Verified Buyer

Sweepstakes Entry

Reviewed at

gap.com/

Comments about Organic Cotton Poplin Big Shirt

Perfect petite button down shirt. Fits perfectly, feels good on, and is a go to wardrobe staple.

Bad quality

Submitted 7 days ago

By María

From Undisclosed

Reviewed at

gap.com/

I hated it, poor quality

Way to big

Submitted 26 days ago

By anonymous

From Undisclosed

Verified Buyer

Sweepstakes Entry

Comments about Organic Cotton Poplin Big Shirt

Way too large! Size down!

Love it

Submitted 1 month ago

By anonymous

From Undisclosed

Height 5'11"

Verified Buyer

Sweepstakes Entry

Comments about Organic Cotton Poplin Big Shirt

Great fit

Wider stripes are fun to wear

Submitted 1 month ago

By anonymous

From Undisclosed

Verified Buyer

Sweepstakes Entry

Comments about Organic Cotton Poplin Big Shirt

I really like the bright blue colour and the wider stripes of this shirt. It does fit very oversized. Definitely size down so that you are not swamped.

Fit

Submitted 1 month ago

By anonymous

From Undisclosed

Height 5'10"

Verified Buyer

Sweepstakes Entry

Comments about Organic Cotton Poplin Big Shirt

Looks great with jeans. At 5ft 10, 145 lbs, medium fits big.

Image different than what I received

Submitted 1 month ago

By Niko k

From Undisclosed

I've been buying the big shirt since they came out, I really like them. But there are a few that have a different collar and sleeve, and I don't like those. I can't pop the collar the same, or roll the sleeve up how I like to. The blue and white stripe shirt shows the old style of sleeve and collar, but when I received it it's not. So a return.